Tips For Developing Effective Supervisor-Student Relationships

Image Source: Canva (2023)

Your supervisor is not just an academic advisor - they are a crucial partner in your research journey. The quality of your relationship with your supervisor can influence everything from your motivation and academic confidence to the overall success of your research project. A positive and professional dynamic can provide encouragement, valuable feedback, and much-needed structure, while a strained relationship can lead to delays, confusion, and avoidable frustration.

For many postgraduate candidates, particularly those balancing professional and academic commitments, developing a supportive working relationship with their supervisor is essential. However, this relationship is not automatic; it must be developed intentionally and respectfully. Understanding the expectations, communication preferences, and working style of your supervisor can greatly enhance your experience and outcomes.

We hope this post will offer practical tips to help you manage and strengthen the supervisor-student relationship from the beginning of your academic programme and throughout the research process:

1. Initial Meeting Preparation

Before your first formal meeting, take the time to research your supervisor's academic background, including their research interests, recent publications, and any current projects. This context helps you understand their perspective and how your proposed topic may align with their expertise. Bring a clear agenda to the meeting, outlining your preliminary research ideas, any areas you are unsure about, and specific goals you would like to achieve in the short and medium term. Prepare a few thoughtful questions that reflect your engagement with their work and your desire to shape your project with informed guidance.

This first meeting also sets the tone for your working relationship. Demonstrating initiative, curiosity, and preparedness helps build mutual respect. It is also worth noting that when your supervisor's research interests align closely with your topic, the relationship often runs more smoothly. Shared academic interests can lead to more meaningful feedback, a deeper understanding of your work, and more efficient problem-solving throughout your research journey. That said, in the absence of an alignment of research interests, your approach to your project can help expand your supervisor's knowledge of your field.

2. Clear Communication

Establishing clear and open lines of communication is foundational to a healthy supervisor-student relationship. Communication is not simply about sharing updates - it involves being responsive, respectful, and intentional in how you convey information and how you receive feedback. In addition to expressing your ideas and updates, make an effort to actively listen to your supervisor’s suggestions, critiques, and questions. Never leave a meeting without asking questions, jotting down points or taking note of potential areas of concern. These moments often provide key insights that can guide and strengthen your work. While I was a student, I often asked my supervisor if I could record our meetings, as voice notes on my phone, to review later. This allowed me to be present in the meeting and to ensure that I did not miss any important points made.

It is also important to develop the habit of providing structured and concise progress updates. Whether you are submitting a new draft or checking in via email, outline what has been completed, what is underway, and where you might need support or clarification. If you are struggling with a particular section or experiencing delays due to personal, professional, or academic challenges, be transparent as early as possible. Many students may opt to choose silence or simply disappear when they are struggling or too busy to look at their research, but most supervisors appreciate being kept in the loop, particularly when issues are flagged early enough to allow for support or adjustments.

Regularly scheduled check-ins - whether biweekly, monthly, or at another agreed interval - help keep both parties aligned on the research’s trajectory. Consistent communication also helps prevent misunderstandings and ensures that feedback and support are timely and relevant to your stage of progress. It also keeps your project top of mind for your supervisor, which can be helpful if any opportunities arise to publish, present or attend any events that can boost your academic CV.

3. Set Clear Expectations

From the outset of your research journey, it is critical to establish and clarify mutual expectations. This means having an open discussion with your supervisor about the frequency of meetings, preferred methods of communication (e.g., email, in-person, online platforms), and anticipated timelines for receiving feedback on drafts or other submissions.

Equally important is aligning expectations around the level of guidance your supervisor is comfortable providing. Some supervisors take a more hands-on approach, while others expect students to work independently and reach out when needed. Understanding these dynamics early can help prevent frustration and miscommunication later in the process.

Additionally, identify key project milestones - such as proposal submission, ethics approval, data collection, or chapter drafts - and ensure both parties are clear on what is required and when. If there are institutional deadlines or personal time constraints (such as professional obligations or family responsibilities), raise these early to build realistic plans and reduce last-minute stress. If you are expected to submit a draft of a chapter, ensure your supervisor has confirmed their availability to review it. Without this confirmation, you might submit the draft and feel frustrated by delays, only to discover they are attending a conference or managing test or exam-related responsibilities. You may then realise you could have used that time to refine your draft instead of rushing for it to sit unopened in their inbox.

When expectations are clearly defined and agreed upon, the supervisory relationship tends to be more productive, collaborative, and respectful - allowing both the student and the supervisor to engage meaningfully and with a shared sense of direction.

4. Act on Feedback

View constructive feedback as a crucial component of your academic development rather than a personal critique. Research, by its nature, is iterative and requires refinement - feedback is part of this process. While some comments may feel discouraging at first, give yourself the space to reflect before reacting. Aim to understand the core of what is being communicated and how it can strengthen your work. Avoid viewing constructive feedback as an attack on your capabilities or potential. Reframe the concept of feedback as the main method of learning when conducting research. Something to help you improve as opposed to viewing it as something designed to hold you back.

Respond to all your supervisor’s feedback with professionalism and purpose. Do not choose which feedback to address and which to ignore. Ignoring some feedback can cause you to make the same mistake with each draft presented. Address each comment systematically, showing that you are taking the time to engage with their input and apply it meaningfully. This not only helps improve the quality of your research but also builds trust and mutual respect in your relationship.

If any feedback seems unclear or contradictory, seek clarification respectfully and with the intention of better understanding their expectations. This proactive approach reinforces your dedication to the research process and demonstrates that you are invested in producing rigorous, high-quality work. Remember, acting on feedback is not simply about making corrections - it is about evolving as a researcher. Much of what every research candidate will learn will come from the type of feedback they receive.

5. Regular Check-ins

Consistent engagement with your supervisor through scheduled check-ins is vital for maintaining momentum in your research journey. These meetings provide a structured opportunity to reflect on your progress, flag any challenges, and plan the next steps in a focused, collaborative manner. Rather than waiting for issues to escalate, check-ins create a rhythm of accountability that allows for timely intervention and support.

Depending on your level of study, the complexity of your project, and your supervisor’s availability, you may agree to meet every two weeks, monthly, or at another suitable interval. The key is to find a cadence that supports your progress without placing undue pressure on either party. Meetings can take place in person, online, or via telephone - what matters most is that they are purposeful and that both parties come prepared.

Use these sessions to not only update your supervisor on your work but to raise questions, test ideas, and gain feedback that informs your direction. A consistent check-in routine helps create a professional, responsive working relationship and ensures that your supervisor remains informed and engaged throughout your academic journey. I will mention it again, do not disappear without communicating with your supervisor to inform them about what is currently impacting your progress.

6. Be Proactive

Taking initiative is a critical aspect of establishing yourself as a serious and capable researcher. Rather than waiting for direction, make it a habit to actively move your research forward. This includes identifying potential issues early, proposing thoughtful solutions, and remaining engaged with the literature in your field to inform your ideas. When you come to meetings with new insights, prepared questions, and relevant readings, it demonstrates a high level of commitment and intellectual curiosity.

Being proactive does not mean working in isolation - it means showing that you are invested in your work and willing to take responsibility for your progress. This independence is often expected at postgraduate level, and supervisors generally appreciate students who take ownership of their research journey. It also helps build mutual respect, as it signals that you are motivated, value your supervisor’s time and are prepared to use it productively.

Proactive behaviour not only strengthens the quality of your research, but it can also help develop a more collaborative and enthusiastic relationship with your supervisor. When they see that you are genuinely invested, they are often more inclined to provide in-depth guidance, recommend resources, and even recommend you for opportunities they come across.

7. Respect Timelines

Before you start drafting a document for submission, ask your supervisor when in their calendar they would be available to review it, then work according to that. Adhering to agreed-upon deadlines is an essential part of maintaining a respectful and professional working relationship with your supervisor. When you consistently meet your submission timelines for chapters, drafts, or other deliverables, it reflects your commitment to the research process and your ability to manage your time effectively. It also signals that you value your supervisor’s time and are mindful of the many other responsibilities they may be balancing.

Supervisors often work with multiple students and juggle various academic and administrative duties. Submitting your work on time allows them to allocate sufficient time to provide thoughtful, constructive feedback without unnecessary pressure. Late submissions, particularly without communication, may not only delay your own progress but could also strain the working relationship.

If you anticipate missing a deadline due to unforeseen circumstances, it is best to communicate this early. Being transparent and proposing a revised timeline demonstrates maturity and helps maintain trust. In the long run, developing this discipline will support the smooth progress of your project.

8. Document Agreements

It is important to maintain accurate records of all key decisions and agreements made during your meetings with your supervisor. This includes clarifying feedback, setting deadlines, outlining next steps, and noting any changes to your research direction. Keeping a detailed log or summary ensures that both parties are aligned and can return to the same point of reference should any confusion arise later. One effective way to do this is by following up each meeting with a brief email summarising the key points discussed, outlining your next steps, and confirming expectations. This practice enables transparency, reduces misunderstandings, and reflects a high level of professionalism in how you manage your project. It can also be a helpful and reliable record of your progress for progress reports.

9. Seek Professional Development

Use your time with your supervisor not only to discuss research progress but also to explore opportunities for professional growth, where relevant. Supervisors can often provide insight into upcoming conferences, publication opportunities, academic workshops, or industry events relevant to your research area. These activities can help you strengthen your research profile, build your academic network, and gain confidence in presenting your work to wider audiences. Participating in such initiatives also demonstrates initiative and enthusiasm for your field, which may positively influence your academic and professional trajectory. Where relevant, you may also find that these engagements clarify your long-term goals and open up pathways beyond your current studies.

10. Maintain a Positive Attitude

Where possible, try to approach challenges in your research journey with a positive mindset, viewing them as opportunities for learning and improvement. Develop a collaborative and supportive relationship with your supervisor, creating an environment conducive to productive research. A positive attitude not only enhances the quality of your work but also contributes to a fulfilling research experience. It is understood that research can oftentimes leave one feeling negative and unmotivated. However, it is always important to acknowledge that both your supervisor and institution share a similar goal to you, which is to see you succeed as best as possible. Sometimes 

remembering this can help to keep a positive attitude during tough experiences.

Remember, effective communication and mutual respect form the foundation of a successful supervisor-student relationship. By adhering to these guidelines, you can maximise the benefits of this collaboration and elevate the quality of your research.

Wishing you all the best!

Dr. Chenai Muhwati, PhD